.35 Remington vs. 360 Buckhammer: Which Wins?
Americans love lever guns, and they love arguing about what should go in them even more. The matchup here sets a cartridge from 1906 against one from 2023: the .35 Remington, which ranks as the best-known of the .35-caliber cartridges, and the 360 Buckhammer, a straight-walled design Remington built to satisfy the deer regulations of several Midwestern states. Both drive .358-inch bullets through tubular-magazine lever actions at similar velocities, and the game at the other end is unlikely to tell them apart. What separates them is pressure, legality, and the depth of the rifle and ammunition catalogs behind each. Here is how they line up, and which one you should buy.
The .35 Remington
Case and design
The .35 Remington arrived in 1906, one of four rimless cartridges built for the autoloader that became the Model 8. Its three siblings, the .25, .30, and .32 Remington, have all but vanished. The .35 endured.
The case runs a rim diameter of .460 inch and measures 1.920 inches in length. Being rimless, headspace falls to the shoulder, which measures 23 degrees, 25 minutes. The neck sits just shy of the one-caliber length that gives good neck tension. The tubular magazines on most lever guns mean you will see a healthy crimp on the ammunition.
Reputation and rifles
Traditional loads send a 200-grain bullet out at a hair under 2,100 fps. That low-recoiling combination has made the cartridge a favorite of the woods hunter for more than a century. It carries a stellar reputation among the people who use it. Plenty of them will tell you it outperforms the .30-30 Winchester on deer and bear by a clear margin.
The .35 Remington was never designed to be a lever cartridge. Yet that is where it found its home, back when Marlin chambered the round in the Model 336 in 1953. The Marlin Model 336 is the rifle most responsible for the cartridge’s standing, and the revived Marlin has confirmed the Model 336 is returning in .35 Remington.
Ammunition options
The .35 Remington’s standout strength is the breadth of its support. Factory ammunition is available from Remington, Federal, Winchester, Buffalo Bore, and Hornady, with bullet weights running from 150 to 230 grains.
Among those, the Hornady LEVERevolution .35 Remington is the obvious choice for a hunter who wants a modern pointed bullet that feeds safely in a tubular magazine and extends the cartridge’s reach. For hunters who want the heaviest, hardest-hitting load, the Buffalo Bore Heavy .35 Remington 220-grain pushes its 220-grain bullet to 2,200 fps, which answers anyone who argues the cartridge runs out of steam at the top end.
The trade-off
The trade-off is twofold. First, the .35 Remington’s case length and neck profile rule it out in many straight-wall states, so it is off the table where those rules apply. Second, its pressure ceiling is lower than the Buckhammer’s, loaded to 33,500 psi, and its velocity trails accordingly.
There is also a question of future availability. The only maker offering a .35 Remington rifle was Henry, with a single model, before Marlin’s Model 336 announcement. The rimless case is a harder conversion for manufacturers than a rimmed one, and that difficulty has fed a prediction that the cartridge is on its way out.
The 360 Buckhammer
Case and design
The 360 Buckhammer debuted in 2023 at the SHOT Show in Las Vegas. Remington built it as a direct answer to the straight-wall rules in states like Ohio, Illinois, Iowa, Michigan, and Indiana, many of which limited hunters to shotgun slugs or muzzleloaders for years.
Remington took the classic .30-30 Winchester case, removed the bottleneck, and expanded the mouth to accept .358-inch bullets. The case was shortened to 1.800 inches. Maximum cartridge length tops out at 2 1/2 inches, and the result meets the specific length and straight-walled profile those laws require.
Velocity and feeding
Because it runs at a higher pressure, 50,000 psi against the .35 Remington’s 33,500, the Buckhammer holds a velocity edge. Its 180-grain loads clear the muzzle at 2,400 fps. The 200-grain bullets move at 2,200 fps, a slight but real advantage over conventional .35 Remington loads.
The rimmed case, which shares the .30-30’s rim diameter, feeds without trouble in a tubular magazine. It also suits single-shot rifles, bolt actions, and revolvers. The cartridge has shown surprising accuracy from a Henry lever action, and it has taken a Texas Dall ram cleanly with one shot from a Rossi rifle.
Legality and support
The cartridge’s standout strength is that legality. Where state law demands a straight-walled cartridge, the Buckhammer is a logical .35-caliber choice, and the .35 Remington is not.
Its standard hunting load is the Remington Core-Lokt 360 Buckhammer, sending 180- and 200-grain Core-Lokt bullets at the velocities above. For hunters in jurisdictions that require non-lead projectiles or who simply prefer them, Remington offers the lead-free Remington Copper 360 Buckhammer. Rifle support, while younger, is already solid: the Henry lever-action rifle in 360 Buckhammer and the Rossi lever-action rifle in 360 Buckhammer both chamber it, and Henry has offered multiple lever guns plus a single-shot in the cartridge.
The trade-off
The trade-off is pedigree and reach. The Buckhammer is new, and its ammunition and rifle catalogs, though growing quickly, remain thinner than the .35 Remington’s.
Factory loads come from Remington and Federal only, against the five makers behind the older round. And its usefulness is tied to the straight-wall regulations that created it. Should those states eventually open to conventional rifle cartridges, the demand that drives the Buckhammer could dwindle.
The Differences That Decide It
Performance is a wash
Start with the numbers, because they settle less than you might expect. The Buckhammer runs faster and hits a touch harder, courtesy of its higher pressure, but the gap over the .35 Remington is slim.
Both cartridges drive 180- and 200-grain bullets to similar velocities, both feed reliably in tubular-magazine lever guns, and the recoil difference between them is nearly indiscernible. The Buffalo Bore Heavy .35 Remington 220-grain even matches the Buckhammer’s 200-grain velocity with a heavier bullet. No deer or bear is going to register which one you fired.
Where you hunt
With performance a wash, the decision comes down to two things: where you hunt, and what you can buy. Where you hunt is the sharper of the two.
If your season falls in a straight-wall state, the .35 Remington’s case length and neck design put it out of bounds, and the 360 Buckhammer becomes the sensible, legal pick. Outside those states, that advantage evaporates, and the question becomes one of selection.
What you can buy
On selection, the .35 Remington holds the lead that comes with a century-plus head start. Five makers load it against the Buckhammer’s two, the bullet-weight range is slightly wider, and the number of rifles chambered for it, bolstered by the returning Marlin Model 336, outnumbers what exists for the newer round.
The Buckhammer is closing that gap fast, with multiple rifles and several factory loads already available only a short time after launch. But it has not yet earned the popularity or pedigree the .35 Remington carries.
A note on manufacturing
One wrinkle worth noting is manufacturing. The Buckhammer shares the .30-30’s rim diameter, which makes it a more straightforward conversion for a rifle maker than the rimless .35 Remington. That ease could shape what shows up on gun-store shelves in the years ahead. It is a fair bet the newer cartridge sells more new rifles than the older one going forward.
The Verdict
For straight-wall states
For the hunter who lives and hunts in a straight-wall state, the choice is made for you: buy the 360 Buckhammer. It delivers .35-caliber performance in a case the law allows, it feeds flawlessly in a lever gun, and its ammunition and rifle options are more than adequate for deer work.
Pair the Remington Core-Lokt 360 Buckhammer with a Henry lever-action rifle in 360 Buckhammer or a Rossi lever-action rifle in 360 Buckhammer, and reach for the lead-free Remington Copper 360 Buckhammer where non-toxic ammunition is required or preferred.
For everywhere else
For everyone else, the .35 Remington takes the edge, and does so on the strength of its catalog rather than its ballistics. The deeper lineup of rifles, anchored by the returning Marlin Model 336, and the wider spread of factory ammunition make it the more sensible buy outside the restricted states.
Load it with the Hornady LEVERevolution .35 Remington for a flatter-shooting pointed bullet in a tubular magazine, or step up to the Buffalo Bore Heavy .35 Remington 220-grain when you want the heaviest payload the cartridge offers.
The 360 Buckhammer is an excellent design, and nobody should steer a shooter who wants something a bit out of the ordinary away from it. But until it builds the pedigree the older cartridge already owns, the .35 Remington wins this one.
The post .35 Remington vs. 360 Buckhammer: Which Wins? appeared first on AllOutdoor.com.