76 Days Later, No Charges for Arizona Homeowner Who Shot Alleged Intruder at His Window With Two Small Children Inside

By Luke McCoy •

Key Takeaways

  • A Saint David, Arizona homeowner shot and killed 67-year-old Daniel Elzy on August 30 after hearing a window break and seeing someone outside.
  • The homeowner was inside with his family, including two small children, when he fired at a shadow near the window.
  • Cochise County investigators reviewed Arizona's Castle Doctrine, self-defense laws, forensic evidence, and consulted the county attorney's office before reaching a decision.
  • County Attorney Lori Zucco said the case findings and Arizona law on justified force showed charges against the homeowner were not warranted.
  • The Cochise County Sheriff's Office and County Attorney's Office announced the no-charges decision 76 days after the shooting.

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

SAINT DAVID, AZ — A homeowner who shot and killed a man he believed was trying to get in through a window on Aug. 30 will not face charges. The Cochise County Sheriff’s Office and the Cochise County Attorney’s Office announced the decision Saturday, 76 days after the shooting.

The shooting happened in a neighborhood in Saint David, a small town just south of Benson, as reported by AZFamily. The man who died was 67-year-old Daniel Elzy, who authorities say lived in the Saint David area.

According to the sheriff’s office, the homeowner was inside with his family, including two small children, when he heard a window break. He checked his home security system. He saw someone standing just outside.

The homeowner told deputies he went into the main living area and spotted a shadow near a window that appeared to be someone trying to get inside. He fired.

Benson police officers were the first to arrive. They found a man lying outside the home’s window. Despite efforts to save him, Elzy died at the scene.

Then came the review. Investigators weighed Arizona’s Castle Doctrine along with the state’s laws on self-defense and defense of others, and they consulted the county attorney’s office. Under Arizona law, deadly force is justified only in defense of the homeowner or another person.

County Attorney Lori Zucco said a charging decision has to rest on whether the evidence supports a prosecutable crime. She said the case findings, the forensic evidence, and Arizona law on justified force showed charges against the homeowner “are not warranted.”

“The legal process requires that decisions be made based on evidence and the law, rather than emotion or speculation,” Zucco said. “We believe that standard has been met in this matter.”

Sheriff Mark Dannels called the shooting “an unfortunate and tragic incident that resulted in the loss of a human life.” He said investigators set out to be thorough and impartial.

“Our job is not to reach a popular conclusion, but to reach the appropriate conclusion supported by facts and evidence,” Dannels said. “We believe the appropriate conclusion has been reached.”

Both agencies offered condolences to Elzy’s family. With the review finished, the case is closed and no charges will be filed against the homeowner.

Look at the timeline. The decision to fire came in the seconds after a window broke in a house with two small children inside. The answer on whether that decision was a crime took 76 days. Prosecutors ultimately found charges were not warranted, and that is still how long it took. For those 11 weeks, the outcome was in the hands of investigators and a prosecutor working through forensic evidence and state law.

Even a shooting that ends with no charges runs through an investigation, a legal review, and a long wait. Investigators work the scene and the forensic evidence. A prosecutor weighs the facts against state law. None of that runs on your schedule, and none of it is in your control.

Part of a defensive mindset is planning for what happens after the shot, not just the moment of it. It is easy to put all the focus on gear and range time. It is harder to sit down and think through who you would call after a defensive shooting, how you would get legal help, and how you would pay for it. Those are questions to answer now, while you have time to think clearly, not in the hours after the worst night of your life.

That is why I tell readers to have self-defense coverage in place before they ever need it, and CCW Safe is where I point them. CCW Safe offers self-defense coverage for people who carry, with numerous plans so you can choose the one that fits your needs.

More from USA Carry:

Think about those 76 days again. Coverage does not make the investigation go away. The forensic review still happens, and a prosecutor still makes the call. What changes is how you go through it. Knowing CCW Safe has your back means you are not starting from zero, trying to figure out where to turn while the review plays out. That peace of mind matters in a process you do not control.

Look through the plans, see what each one includes, and pick the one that fits your situation. Make that decision on a calm day instead of a bad one.

Read the original story: 76 Days Later, No Charges for Arizona Homeowner Who Shot Alleged Intruder at His Window With Two Small Children Inside