ATF Reportedly Destroyed 39 Guns Belonging to Oklahoma Pastor Before Trump Pardon

By Duncan Johnson Editor in Chief •
AR-15 Detail in Black and White iStock-534364755
Russell Fincher received a presidential pardon in September 2026, but ATF reportedly destroyed 39 of his forfeited firearms before clemency was granted. iStock-534364755

President Donald Trump granted Oklahoma pastor Russell Fincher a full and unconditional pardon in September, but 39 of his personal firearms reportedly will never be returned. According to the Second Amendment Foundation (SAF), the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) destroyed the guns months before the president intervened in Fincher’s federal firearms case.

In a November 19 investigation, SAF’s Investigative Journalism Project reported that ATF Director Robert Cekada personally informed Fincher that his forfeited firearms were gone. Cekada reportedly provided documentation listing all 39 guns as destroyed on June 12, 2026, nearly three months before Trump issued his pardon.

Now Fincher wants proof that his firearms were actually destroyed, and SAF has filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request seeking video evidence of the destruction. The dispute raises serious questions about ATF’s handling of seized firearms, the accountability of federal agents, and what happens when a gun owner receives presidential clemency after the government has already disposed of his property.

From an ATF Raid to Federal Firearm Forfeiture

Fincher’s battle with the ATF began in June 2023, when heavily armed federal agents descended on his home in Tuskahoma, Oklahoma. Fincher, a Baptist pastor, high school history teacher, and federally licensed firearms dealer, operated a small firearms business and regularly attended gun shows.

As reported in July 2023, Fincher described being handcuffed on his porch while agents searched his home and pressured him to surrender his Federal Firearms License (FFL). His 13-year-old son witnessed the encounter.

According to Fincher, agents seized more than 50 personally owned firearms worth an estimated $50,000 to $60,000. The collection included several Glocks, a Colt Commander, and a valuable pre-ban Polytech AK underfolder. These were not simply inexpensive firearms that could be replaced with another trip to the gun shop. Some were collectible guns Fincher had spent years acquiring.

The raid eventually resulted in a three-count federal indictment alleging unlicensed firearms dealing, selling ammunition to a prohibited person, and making a false entry in firearms records.

In AmmoLand’s May 2024 coverage of Fincher’s plea agreement, the publication detailed how Fincher agreed to plead guilty to selling ammunition to a prohibited person. The negotiated agreement contemplated three years of probation and required him not to contest the forfeiture of 39 personal firearms.

According to SAF, Fincher was allowed to retain 13 other firearms, which he subsequently sold to help pay his family’s bills after the prosecution disrupted his livelihood. The 39 forfeited guns remained with the federal government, including firearms Fincher considered among the most valuable in his collection.

ATF Director Says the Guns Were Destroyed Before Trump’s Pardon

On September 3, 2026, President Trump granted Fincher a full and unconditional presidential pardon in United States v. Fincher, No. 6:23-CR-197. The official clemency warrant is published by the Department of Justice’s Office of the Pardon Attorney.

The pardon addressed Fincher’s federal conviction, but it could not physically bring back firearms that the government had already destroyed. Whether the forfeited property could otherwise have been recovered is a separate legal question.

According to SAF, Cekada spoke with Fincher after the pardon and told him his firearms had been destroyed. Fincher recalled being told the destruction happened in August, but documents Cekada subsequently supplied reportedly identify June 12, 2026, as the actual destruction date. That discrepancy remains unexplained.

The documentation, described as a “Report of Destruction,” reportedly lists all 39 firearms. However, the underlying ATF report has not been independently authenticated or made available for review in the sources examined for this article.

Fincher remains troubled by the lack of evidence showing what physically happened to his collection.

“Prove to me—show me the evidence they were destroyed—show me the video,” Fincher told SAF.

His concerns are understandable. Federal agents took possession of valuable private property, and the owner now faces the prospect of never recovering those firearms, despite receiving presidential clemency.

ATF Says There Is No Video of the Firearms Being Destroyed

The situation became even more frustrating when Fincher asked about video footage of the destruction.

According to SAF, Fincher initially understood that Cekada had indicated the destruction took place at an ATF facility in West Virginia and was recorded. However, Cekada subsequently clarified in text messages reported by SAF that the cameras he had seen were apparently installed for facility security rather than to document firearm destruction.

Cekada reportedly confirmed that no video of the actual destruction process exists.

The ATF director also described the procedures followed by the agency’s National Destruction Branch, which handles firearm destruction for Department of Justice law-enforcement components.

According to Cekada’s explanation, personnel document receipt of firearms authorized for destruction, verify each gun’s make, model, and serial number, and complete a destruction report. The information is subsequently entered into the DOJ’s Consolidated Asset Tracking System, which tracks seized and forfeited property.

Those procedures may create a paper trail, but they do not provide the independent visual confirmation Fincher requested.

SAF reports that its Investigative Journalism Project filed a FOIA request on November 17 seeking video of the destruction. Cekada’s subsequent explanation suggests that no destruction-specific recording exists, leaving the underlying inventory and disposition records as particularly important evidence.

There is currently no independently verified evidence that Fincher’s firearms were stolen, diverted, or improperly disposed of. Nevertheless, an agency exercising the extraordinary power to permanently confiscate and destroy private property should be expected to provide a clear, verifiable accounting of what happened to it.

Presidential Pardons Have Not Ended the Problems for Gun Owners

Fincher’s missing firearms are not the only reported difficulty involving gun owners recently pardoned by President Trump.

In October, SAF reported that Fincher and former Navy sailor Patrick “Tate” Adamiak were denied firearm purchases after receiving presidential pardons. Fincher reportedly attempted to purchase a Smith & Wesson Victory pistol, while Adamiak attempted to purchase a commemorative Thompson-style firearm.

Both transactions were reportedly denied through the federal background-check process despite their presidential clemency.

Cekada told SAF that those denials were an FBI matter rather than an ATF decision. The reasons for the denials and whether they have since been resolved remain unclear.

As AmmoLand previously reported, Adamiak returned home in September after receiving a presidential pardon following years in federal prison over an ATF firearms prosecution involving firearm parts and other collectible items.

These cases illustrate a disturbing practical reality: Receiving presidential clemency does not necessarily mean the federal bureaucracy immediately stops creating obstacles for the people who received it.

There is also an important distinction between restoring rights following a conviction and recovering property already forfeited under a federal court order. Fincher agreed not to contest the forfeiture of his firearms as part of his plea arrangement. A presidential pardon does not automatically reverse that forfeiture or establish a right to recover property that the government has already destroyed.

That legal distinction does not make the destruction of privately owned firearms any less worthy of public scrutiny.

ATF Must Account for the 39 Firearms

The central question is no longer whether President Trump pardoned Russell Fincher. The DOJ’s official warrant establishes that he did. The unanswered question is whether ATF can produce sufficient documentation to demonstrate precisely what happened to Fincher’s 39 forfeited firearms.

The agency reportedly maintains records identifying each firearm by make, model, and serial number. Those records should allow the government to explain when the guns were received for destruction, when they were destroyed, and who documented their disposition.

There is also a broader policy question: Should federal authorities destroy forfeited firearms while the former owner is actively seeking presidential clemency, particularly when there is no apparent urgency requiring their destruction?

For Fincher, those questions are personal. He spent years acquiring firearms that held both financial and sentimental value, only to lose them during a federal prosecution that President Trump ultimately chose to pardon.

The Second Amendment protects a fundamental individual right, not a privilege dispensed at the convenience of federal regulators. Although the Constitution does not automatically undo a completed forfeiture, the government should still be held accountable for how it handles property taken from American gun owners.

A presidential pardon may address the consequences of a criminal conviction, but it cannot replace a collectible rifle, restore a cherished handgun, or undo the physical destruction of a firearm.

If ATF destroyed every one of Fincher’s 39 guns, it should be able to prove it. Until the supporting records are independently examined, the American public is being asked to accept the agency’s reported account of what happened to those firearms.

This development was identified through the AmmoLand 2A NewsRoom. The November 19 destruction allegations and statements attributed to ATF Director Robert Cekada were reported by the Second Amendment Foundation’s Investigative Journalism Project. The presidential pardon was independently confirmed through the U.S. Department of Justice.


About Duncan Johnson:

Duncan Johnson is a lifelong firearms enthusiast and unwavering defender of the Second Amendment—where “shall not be infringed” means exactly what it says. A graduate of George Mason University, he enjoys competing in local USPSA and multi-gun competitions whenever he’s not covering the latest in gun rights and firearm policy. Duncan is a regular contributor and editor-in-chief for AmmoLand News and is responsible for AmmoLand’s daily gun-rights reporting and industry coverage.Duncan Johnson