Baltimore Man Acquitted in Road Rage Shooting After Firing at Motorist Following Him Into Gas Station

By Luke McCoy •

Key Takeaways

  • A Baltimore jury acquitted Donell Trusty Jr., 41, on all counts including attempted second-degree murder in a May 13 road rage shooting.
  • The incident began when Trusty and another driver argued, and Trusty admitted he pushed in the other driver's side-view mirrors as he drove away.
  • The other driver followed Trusty to a gas station, where Trusty fired at the other driver's vehicle, with surveillance footage reportedly corroborating the shooting.
  • Trusty testified he called 911 and kept a dispatcher on the line while still moving, and his attorney played that call for jurors.
  • The prosecutor argued Trusty fired nine times while the other vehicle was driving away, while the defense said Trusty believed his life was in danger.

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

BALTIMORE, MD — A Baltimore jury on Thursday, Nov. 12, acquitted 41-year-old Donell Trusty Jr. of all counts in a May 13 shooting that grew out of a traffic dispute and ended with Trusty firing at another driver’s vehicle outside a gas station. The counts included attempted second-degree murder, first-degree assault, use of a firearm in the commission of a crime of violence, reckless endangerment and discharging a firearm in Baltimore City.

The verdict, closing arguments and trial testimony are as reported by Baltimore Witness. Details from opening statements, along with the name of the presiding judge, Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Martin H. Schreiber III, come from Hoodline’s summary of that outlet’s earlier trial coverage.

Trusty walked out cleared. I still read this case as a list of things a concealed carrier should not do, with one thing worth copying.

The state’s version starts small. According to charging documents, Trusty tried to drive around another vehicle and struck its side-view mirror. In opening statements, prosecutors said it was a rainy night and that honking and yelling followed. The other driver later followed Trusty to a gas station, where he alleged Trusty fired into his vehicle. Surveillance footage reportedly corroborated that allegation.

Trusty’s version, from the witness stand, starts with a double-parked car. He testified that he had never met the other driver and that the two argued after the man refused to move his vehicle. As Trusty drove away, he admitted, he pushed in the other driver’s side-view mirrors.

By Trusty’s own account, then, the first physical act in this encounter was his. His defense was that he was not the aggressor, and the jury acquitted him. But when you carry a gun, a parking argument is not something to win. Pushing in another driver’s mirrors in anger escalates the situation at the exact moment a carrier should be de-escalating it, and it hands a prosecutor the first chapter of a story about who started it.

Trusty testified that the other driver then followed him, pulled out a gun and threatened to “blow his f***ing head off.” In opening statements, defense attorney Martin Cohen went further and told jurors the other driver fired first. Cohen also said Trusty told officers there was a semiautomatic handgun in the other driver’s center console. Police confirmed a handgun was there.

Here is the part every carrier should copy. Trusty testified that he kept driving while calling 911 and asked the operator to stay on the line. Cohen played that call for jurors, along with body camera footage from the scene, to argue Trusty was cooperative and consistent in his statements to police. A dispatcher on the line while you are still moving builds a record, in real time, of who was following whom.

Then he stopped. On cross-examination, the prosecutor asked how Trusty had time to park, exit his car and begin shooting while the other driver was still pulling into the gas station. Trusty answered that the other driver had a gun as he entered the parking lot.

If you believe the person following you is armed, a gas station is not a finish line. Every second spent parking and stepping out of the car is a second the state can argue you had another option. Keep driving. Keep the dispatcher on the line. Let police come to you, or drive to a police department. That is a mindset decision made long before anyone pulls in behind you.

Deadly force is justified only against an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm. The prosecution’s closing leaned on the number of shots. The prosecutor emphasized that Trusty fired nine times while the vehicle was driving away and argued he was not in danger when he fired. Cohen countered that Trusty fired because he believed his life was in danger, and that the state failed to prove otherwise beyond a reasonable doubt. When a vehicle is leaving, every round fired after that point gets examined on its own.

More from USA Carry:

The jury heard both accounts and acquitted Trusty on every count. An acquittal means the state did not prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt. It does not tell us which version of events the jurors believed. During trial, Cohen also challenged the police investigation and the credibility of witnesses, and criticized investigators for not gathering additional evidence, including possible Ring doorbell footage.

Trusty was cleared, but he still had to face attempted murder charges and a jury to get there. If you carry in Maryland, knowing the state’s concealed carry laws is the baseline. Staying out of the argument is the rest of it. Leave the mirror alone. Keep driving with 911 on the line. If you do have to fire, know that shots at a vehicle driving away will be weighed one at a time.

Read the original story: Baltimore Man Acquitted in Road Rage Shooting After Firing at Motorist Following Him Into Gas Station