Carry Permit Pulled Over Biker Club Membership: Ninth Circuit Revives Boozefighters Member’s Lawsuit Against San Diego Sheriff

By Luke McCoy •

Key Takeaways

  • A unanimous Ninth Circuit panel revived Kenneth Shilling's lawsuit against San Diego County Sheriff Kelly Martinez over his revoked concealed carry license.
  • Martinez revoked Shilling's carry permit in December 2023 because he belonged to the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club, which she considers a criminal street gang.
  • The Boozefighters, founded in 1946 by World War II veterans, have never been charged with or legally categorized as a criminal street gang.
  • The panel found the district court misunderstood the free association right by requiring Shilling to show the revocation stopped him from riding with the club.
  • The county-specific standard Martinez used to revoke Shilling's license was not required by any California state law, making the county responsible for the decision.

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

SAN DIEGO, CA — A unanimous Ninth Circuit panel on Friday revived Kenneth Shilling’s lawsuit against San Diego County Sheriff Kelly Martinez, who revoked his concealed carry license in December 2023 over his membership in the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club. The panel found the lower court was wrong to throw out the case against the sheriff and the county.

As reported by Courthouse News Service, U.S. Circuit Judge Patrick Bumatay wrote the decision. He was joined by Judges Kenneth Lee and Jennifer Sung. Bumatay found that Shilling sufficiently claimed his right to free association was infringed when the sheriff deprived him of his Second Amendment right.

The original complaint lays out how Shilling got here. He is a Chula Vista resident and a long-time employee of the Chula Vista Elementary School District. Then-Sheriff Anthony C. Ray issued him a carry permit on June 27, 2022, four days after the Supreme Court decided Bruen. On December 4, 2023, Martinez’s office sent him a letter revoking it.

The complaint quotes the department’s policy, which allowed denial or revocation for anyone with “a pattern of or propensity for criminal conduct, as demonstrated by anything in the application or investigation for a license.” The policy says that includes, but is not limited to, “evidence of criminal behavior or a close nexus to a criminal gang.” According to Courthouse News, Martinez believes the Boozefighters are a criminal street gang. The complaint alleges otherwise. It says the club was founded in 1946 by World War II veterans and has never been charged with or legally categorized as a criminal street gang. It also alleges the revocation came with no evidence linking the club or Shilling to unlawful activity.

Shilling sued the County of San Diego and Martinez in federal court on June 17, 2024, under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. That federal civil rights law lets people sue government officials who violate their constitutional rights. He claimed violations of both the First and Second Amendments. The complaint asks the court to reinstate his permit and to bar the county from taking carry licenses “without proof of a crime or specific gang-related activity.” It also asks the court to order the revocation records destroyed so they don’t follow him into future applications.

The district court dismissed the free-association claim on the theory that Shilling had to show the revocation stopped him from associating with the club. Bumatay rejected that reading. “In dismissing this claim, the district court misunderstood the nature of the free association right,” he wrote. “While preventing an individual from participating in a group’s lawful activities may be one way to violate the First Amendment right, it’s infringed in ‘varied ways.’”

That is the correct read. Nobody stopped Shilling from riding with the Boozefighters. The government doesn’t have to bar the clubhouse door to burden association. Attaching a penalty to membership does the job, and here the penalty was his carry license.

The panel also found that Martinez acted as a county policymaker, not a state official, when she revoked the license. In plain terms, the panel says the decision was the county’s own, so the county can be held responsible for it. Bumatay wrote that “No state law mandated this county-specific definition,” and that the county of San Diego, not California, “made association with the Boozefighters a basis to revoke a CCW license.”

The standard Martinez relied on is already gone. Per Courthouse News, California replaced its good moral character requirement with more objective, defined criteria in January 2024, shortly after Shilling lost his license, following Bruen. My California concealed carry guide covers how permits work in the state now.

Gary Gorski, Shilling’s attorney, told Courthouse News in an email that the Bill of Rights prevails over politics.

Friday’s ruling means the lawsuit can move forward. It does not decide whether the revocation was unconstitutional. The claims in the complaint are allegations, and the county and sheriff will get their chance to defend the decision.

The stakes go well past one Chula Vista rider. A carry license is supposed to rest on what the holder has done. If the complaint’s account holds up, this one was pulled over who he rides with, under a county-specific definition no state law required. Anyone carrying in California should understand the mindset here. Your license is only as secure as the standard the issuing agency applies, and that standard can be written at the county level.

More from USA Carry:

I will continue tracking Shilling v. County of San Diego as it moves forward.

Image: By Cullen328 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Redirect/page/190525432

Read the original story: Carry Permit Pulled Over Biker Club Membership: Ninth Circuit Revives Boozefighters Member’s Lawsuit Against San Diego Sheriff