Fifth Circuit Won’t Fast-Track Machine Gun Ban Challenge

By Josh C •
A courtroom of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. (Photo: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit)


Texas gun owners hoping for new machine guns will have to take the long way. On Nov. 4, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, which covers Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas, voted 9-8 against letting its full bench hear a challenge to the federal ban on civilian machine guns made after May 19, 1986, without first going through the usual three-judge panel.


It's a procedural loss, not a ruling on the merits. The ban stays in place, and the case heads to a panel that will almost certainly have to rule against the challengers. If they eventually win, members of the Texas gun club behind the suit could make or buy new machine guns, though still through National Firearms Act registration and the $200 tax. That's several rounds of litigation away.


Who's suing

Temple Gun Club, a Texas nonprofit with more than 1,000 members, filed suit March 10 in federal court in Fort Worth, along with members Jeffrey Howard, Clark Miracle and Jason Armstrong. The defendants are the U.S. attorney general and ATF officials. The club wants a court order barring the government from enforcing the ban against its members.

The target is 18 U.S.C. § 922(o), better known as the Hughes Amendment. It makes it illegal to transfer or possess a machine gun, with exceptions for government use and guns lawfully owned before the ban took effect.

This isn't a Second Amendment case. When a Mississippi federal judge threw out a machine gun charge in 2025, he did it on Second Amendment grounds. Temple Gun Club argues Congress never had the power to pass the ban in the first place. The government defends § 922(o) under the Commerce Clause, which lets Congress regulate commerce among the states. The club says that power doesn't stretch to simply owning a machine gun, especially one made and kept in a single state.


Why skipping the panel mattered

The Fifth Circuit normally hears appeals in three-judge panels, and one panel can't overrule another. Short of a Supreme Court decision that changes the law, only the full court, sitting "en banc," can do that.

There's an old panel ruling standing right in the club's way. In United States v. Knutson (1997), the Fifth Circuit upheld § 922(o) as a valid use of the commerce power. Chief U.S. District Judge Reed O'Connor dismissed the suit on July 22, saying Knutson bound him. So the club asked the full court to take the appeal directly, arguing Knutson would turn panel review into "a meaningless formality." The Justice Department opposed the request, noting that every federal appeals court to consider the question, the Fifth Circuit included, has upheld the ban.


The club needed nine of the court's 17 active judges. It got eight.


The dissent

Judge Andrew S. Oldham dissented, joined by Judge James C. Ho. He opened by quoting himself from earlier this year, when the full court declined to rehear a Second Amendment challenge to the same ban: "As far as I am aware, there is no historical justification for banning machine guns."


Oldham also pointed to United States v. Squire, a Louisiana felon-in-possession case the full court agreed on July 20 to rehear on whether the Commerce Clause supports § 922(g)(1). Section 922(g) at least has a built-in reference to interstate commerce. Section 922(o) doesn't. If that hook matters, Oldham wrote, the machine gun ban is on shakier ground than the felon ban. He also drew a contrast between the two cases: Squire is a repeat drug trafficker, while the Temple Gun Club plaintiffs want to do something that never leaves Texas.


What's next

The appeal goes to a three-judge panel, which is stuck with Knutson unless the law changes. Squire could be what changes it. The Justice Department told the court that once the full court rules in that case, a panel could weigh whether its reasoning applies here. Squire is on the Fifth Circuit's January 2027 en banc calendar.