GOA Submits 111-Page Report Exposing Alleged ATF Gun Registry Ahead of Congressional Hearing

By Duncan Johnson Editor in Chief •
ATF Form 4473 firearm transaction records representing the gun registry controversy before Congress
Congress is examining ATF’s collection of more than 1.4 billion pages of out-of-business firearms records after Gun Owners of America submitted a report challenging the agency’s recordkeeping practices. AI-generated editorial illustration.

Gun Owners of America (GOA) is taking its fight against the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives’ massive firearms records collection directly to Congress, submitting a 111-page report accusing the agency of maintaining an illegal national gun registry containing more than 1.4 billion pages of records from shuttered gun dealers.

The report, titled ATF’s Illegal Gun Owner Registry, was submitted as written testimony by GOA Director of Federal Affairs Aidan Johnston ahead of a House Oversight hearing scheduled for Wednesday, November 18, 2026.

The hearing comes as ATF considers a proposed rule that would end indefinite retention of many firearm transaction records but could still allow the federal government to maintain information about lawful gun purchases for as long as 60 years.

At issue is a fundamental question: Has ATF used its authority to trace firearms recovered during criminal investigations to build the very type of centralized gun ownership database Congress sought to prohibit through the Firearm Owners’ Protection Act of 1986?

The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform’s Subcommittee on Federal Law Enforcement, chaired by Rep. Clay Higgins (R-La.), will examine that question during a hearing scheduled for 2 p.m. Eastern in Room 2154 of the Rayburn House Office Building.

GOA: ATF Has Built a Searchable National Gun Registry

Johnston’s report makes a sweeping accusation: ATF has accumulated a centralized database containing information about American gun owners and the firearms they purchased, despite longstanding federal restrictions on establishing a national firearms registry.

According to the report, ATF disclosed in correspondence with Rep. Michael Cloud (R-Texas) that its out-of-business records collection contained 1,414,088,513 pages or images in 2026.

Those records originate primarily from federal firearms licensees (FFLs) that permanently close their businesses. Federal law requires those dealers to surrender their required transaction records, including ATF Forms 4473 and acquisition-and-disposition records, to the government.

The documents contain identifying information about firearm purchasers, including names, addresses, dates of birth, and details identifying the firearms transferred. The records are maintained through ATF’s National Tracing Center in Martinsburg, West Virginia.

The 1.4 billion figure represents pages or images, not 1.4 billion individual gun owners or firearms. Nevertheless, the extraordinary size of the collection raises serious questions about how much information the federal government has accumulated about Americans exercising their Second Amendment rights.

GOA argues that ATF’s Out-of-Business Records Imaging System (OBRIS) has effectively centralized information that Congress intended to protect from federal registration.

The agency maintains that the system’s search restrictions prevent it from functioning as a conventional gun-owner registry. ATF has described its digital records as searchable through dealer information and firearm identifiers rather than the purchaser’s name.

GOA disputes whether those limitations meaningfully protect gun owners, arguing that modern digital tools could make the underlying information searchable in ways the current system does not permit.

The report goes further, warning that the database could be exploited by a future administration seeking to identify gun owners or particular categories of firearms.

Those warnings concern potential misuse rather than evidence that ATF is currently conducting firearm confiscations through the system. The central concern remains whether the government should possess such an extensive collection of personally identifiable firearm transaction records in the first place.

ATF’s Proposed Reform Could Still Preserve Records for 60 Years

The hearing arrives during a significant regulatory dispute over how long ATF and licensed firearms dealers should be required to maintain transaction records.

In May, ATF published proposed rule RIN 1140-AA95, offering alternatives that would replace indefinite retention of many covered records with either a 20-year or 30-year period.

Although ending indefinite record retention would reverse a significant portion of the Biden administration’s 2022 recordkeeping expansion, the proposed language contains a provision that GOA has strongly criticized.

Under the proposal, a dealer could retain a transaction record for 20 or 30 years before closing. Once the record is surrendered to ATF, a separate retention period would begin, measured from the date the government received it.

Consequently, a record maintained by a dealer for 30 years could remain in ATF custody for another 30 years.

That is potentially six decades of recordkeeping concerning a lawful firearm transaction.

GOA and the Gun Owners Foundation previously objected to the proposal, arguing that transferring records from an FFL to ATF should not restart the retention clock.

Johnston’s congressional report renews that criticism and urges the government to destroy records that GOA considers unlawfully maintained rather than merely shortening their retention period.

For gun owners, the distinction is substantial. Replacing indefinite retention with decades of additional federal storage does not necessarily resolve the underlying dispute over government collection of firearm purchaser information.

Retired ATF Official Disputes Registry Claims but Supports Destroying Older Records

Not everyone appearing before the committee agrees with GOA’s characterization of the system.

Walfred A. “Wally” Nelson, a retired ATF Deputy Assistant Director who previously supervised the National Tracing Center, argues in his written testimony that ATF’s records collection is not a firearms registry.

Nelson maintains that the records are organized and searched for individual firearm traces rather than maintained as a registration system identifying every firearm possessed by a particular individual.

However, his testimony also acknowledges that indefinite accumulation of firearm records cannot continue forever.

Nelson supports restoring a 20-year retention limit for dealers and recommends that ATF retain surrendered records for 30 years after receipt.

His testimony cites ATF figures indicating that approximately 89% of firearm traces involve records less than 20 years old, while approximately 87% involve firearms recovered within 20 years of their original retail sale.

Those numbers are significant because they raise questions about the investigative value of retaining substantially older transaction records.

Nelson also describes a National Tracing Center backlog of approximately 50,000 boxes of paper records, representing roughly 120 million sheets awaiting imaging.

Even someone who previously supervised ATF’s tracing operations is acknowledging that the agency cannot simply accumulate records forever.

FFLGuard Questions ATF’s Authority to Digitize and Retain Gun Records

Christopher Chiafullo, founder and National Coordinating Counsel of FFLGuard, approaches the controversy from the perspective of federally licensed firearms businesses.

His written testimony raises a legal distinction that deserves attention: Requiring a closing firearms dealer to surrender records does not necessarily answer every question about what the government is subsequently authorized to do with those documents.

Chiafullo argues that Congress should examine the legal authority governing ATF’s reproduction, digitization, preservation, and destruction of surrendered records.

He acknowledges previous Government Accountability Office reviews that found the systems examined complied with the statutory and appropriations restrictions addressed in those reviews. But he maintains that Congress should still scrutinize the authority for each stage of the records-handling process.

His testimony supports restoring finite record-retention requirements while questioning whether the government’s existing practices have been adequately justified.

That distinction matters because an agency’s ability to retrieve records by serial number rather than purchaser name does not, by itself, resolve every question about the government’s authority to reproduce and store those records.

Former Biden White House Official Defends ATF’s Records Collection

The committee will also hear from Gregory Jackson, a former Deputy Director of the Biden White House Office of Gun Violence Prevention, appearing as the minority witness.

In his prepared testimony, Jackson defends ATF’s out-of-business records collection as an important investigative resource for law enforcement. He cites ATF data indicating that approximately 52% of crime-gun trace requests submitted between 2000 and 2023 were completed using out-of-business records.

Jackson also references an August 2026 Department of Justice inspector general audit that reported finding no evidence of noncompliance with the federal laws and regulations examined.

Those findings are relevant, although they do not settle every legal and constitutional objection raised by GOA or determine whether current retention practices should continue unchanged.

The dispute ultimately concerns more than whether firearms records can assist investigators. It concerns the limits Congress placed on the federal government’s ability to collect, centralize, and retain information identifying lawful gun owners.

Congress Faces Questions About ATF’s Expanding Digital Records Systems

The out-of-business archive is not the only ATF recordkeeping technology raising questions about federal access to firearm purchaser information.

As AmmoLand previously reported, ATF’s FFL Direct program allows participating firearms dealers to respond electronically to trace requests using information maintained in their own electronic recordkeeping systems.

Unlike the out-of-business archive, FFL Direct is an opt-in system in which the dealer’s underlying records remain with the licensee unless information is transmitted in response to a request. It nevertheless demonstrates how modern tracing technology can rapidly transmit firearm disposition information, including identifying information about purchasers, to the government.

The distinction is important, but so is the broader question of what safeguards prevent information obtained for a specific criminal investigation from becoming part of a wider federal database.

Congress already placed restrictions on the creation of national firearms registration systems. Those restrictions cannot be reduced to a technical debate about whether a particular database has a purchaser-name search field.

Will Congress Demand More Than Another ATF Explanation?

Higgins has made clear that the committee intends to examine whether ATF’s existing practices comply with federal restrictions on firearm registration.

In the committee’s November 16 announcement, Higgins warned that ATF’s proposed multi-decade retention periods raise concerns about maintaining what he described as a backdoor registry.

The hearing will feature Johnston, Nelson, Chiafullo, and Jackson. No currently serving ATF or Department of Justice official appears on the published witness list.

The proceeding also follows a September 24 letter from eight Republican senators demanding that Attorney General Todd Blanche investigate ATF’s records collection and destroy records determined to be unlawfully maintained.

As AmmoLand previously reported, the central issue is whether the federal government’s enormous firearms records archive has moved beyond its tracing function and into territory Congress expressly sought to prohibit.

Wednesday’s hearing will not itself change federal law or require ATF to destroy records. But the newly published testimony puts several important questions before Congress: What information can ATF retrieve, what authority permits its continued retention, and will records that are no longer legally required actually be destroyed?

The Second Amendment does not depend on government permission, and Americans exercising that right have a legitimate expectation that federal agencies will respect the statutory limits Congress imposed on firearms registration.

For decades, gun owners have been required to provide detailed personal information when purchasing firearms through licensed dealers. Congress must now confront what happens when that information eventually finds its way into federal custody.

The hearing and its supporting documents are available through the House Oversight Committee. The controversy is also being tracked by AmmoLand’s 2A NewsRoom.

Related: Congress Sets November 18 Hearing on ATF’s Massive Gun Records Archive


About Duncan Johnson:

Duncan Johnson is a lifelong firearms enthusiast and unwavering defender of the Second Amendment—where “shall not be infringed” means exactly what it says. A graduate of George Mason University, he enjoys competing in local USPSA and multi-gun competitions whenever he’s not covering the latest in gun rights and firearm policy. Duncan is a regular contributor and editor-in-chief for AmmoLand News and is responsible for AmmoLand’s daily gun-rights reporting and industry coverage.Duncan Johnson