Judge Tosses DOJ Suit Over Montgomery County's 100-Yard Gun Ban

By Josh C •
The Montgomery County Council Office Building. (Photo: Montgomery County, Maryland)

In Montgomery County, Maryland, you can't possess a gun within 100 yards of a park, school, library, house of worship, or other place of public assembly. A carry permit only gets you through those zones in a vehicle. DOJ's argument was that a licensed carrier can't realistically get around the county without wandering into one.

Two federal challenges hit milestones last week. On Nov. 9, a judge threw out the Justice Department's suit. On Nov. 10, an Orthodox synagogue asked the Fourth Circuit to let armed members walk to services.


Neither changes the rule yet. According to a September ruling in the synagogue's case, the county State's Attorney has agreed to hold off on prosecutions until that case is resolved, and county police aren't writing criminal citations. Officers can still write civil citations with fines of up to $500 for a first offense, though, and the judge warned that the prosecution pause might not last.


Why DOJ lost

The county rewrote the rule in July with Expedited Bill 23-26, after Maryland's Supreme Court held in Engage Armament that parts of the old version went beyond the county's authority under state law.

DOJ sued on Aug. 3 under 34 U.S.C. § 12601, the statute that lets it go after police departments for a "pattern or practice" of violating constitutional rights. Its theory was creative: The law violates the Second Amendment, so enforcing it would be the pattern or practice.


U.S. District Judge Theodore Chuang wasn't buying it. He dismissed the case and denied a preliminary injunction, finding the complaint "fails to allege a 'pattern or practice of conduct by law enforcement officers.'" Reading the statute DOJ's way would be "a breathtakingly broad expansion of federal power," he wrote.

He never reached whether the law is constitutional. DOJ, which is using the same statute against Glendale, California, has until Jan. 8, 2027, to appeal.


Safe inside, stuck on the sidewalk

Silver Spring Jewish Center and Rabbi J. Menashe Shapiro, a Maryland permit holder, sued the county on July 30. On Sept. 10, U.S. District Judge Deborah Chasanow found they were likely to win their Second Amendment and free exercise claims against the place-of-worship ban, and she blocked enforcement against them for handguns in their own places of worship.


The 100-yard buffer was another matter. Chasanow found the buffer around schools likely constitutional and said Shapiro is "like any other licensed gun carrier." She declined to revisit that on Oct. 27.


That's a real problem for Orthodox Jews, who don't drive on the Sabbath or holidays. The vehicle exception does them no good. According to their motion, Shapiro's only walking route passes within 100 yards of four schools, two parks and three other houses of worship. So the rabbi can be armed in the sanctuary but not on the way there.


They appealed on Nov. 6 and are asking the Fourth Circuit for an injunction covering Shapiro and licensed members on that walk. The county has already told the district court it doesn't oppose relief within the 100 yards around the synagogue itself. Its response to the new motion is due Nov. 17, and the synagogue's opening brief is due Dec. 4.