Pepper Spray Legal, Pepper Launcher a Crime: Federal Judge Pauses Byrna and Two Californians’ Second Amendment Challenge Until Supreme Court Rules
Key Takeaways
- A federal judge paused Schiller v. Bonta on Sept. 3, 2026, waiting for the U.S. Supreme Court to rule in two pending cases.
- Plaintiffs Sandy Schiller, Lucas Alonso-Martinez, and Byrna Technologies sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta over the state's ban on pepper projectile launchers.
- California law allows aerosol pepper spray canisters of 2.5 ounces or smaller but criminalizes launchers that fire pepper irritant as a projectile.
- Byrna says it has sold more than 60,000 launchers in California, but only with hard plastic rounds because pepper rounds cannot legally be sold there.
- The plaintiffs argue pepper projectile launchers are arms protected by the Second Amendment and say California and New York are the only states that criminalize them for ordinary citizens.
Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
SAN DIEGO, CA — A federal lawsuit challenging California’s ban on pepper projectile launchers is on hold until the U.S. Supreme Court rules in two pending cases. On Sept. 3, 2026, Judge Anthony J. Battaglia of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California granted a joint motion to stay Schiller v. Bonta. His order pauses the case pending the Supreme Court’s resolution of the cases it identifies as Viramontes and Grant. A stay means the case stops moving until the court lifts it.
The plaintiffs are Sandy Schiller of San Diego County, Lucas Alonso-Martinez of Orange County, and Byrna Technologies, Inc., a Delaware corporation headquartered in Andover, Massachusetts. They filed their complaint on Dec. 3, 2025, against Rob Bonta in his official capacity as California’s attorney general. The case was first assigned to Judge Thomas J. Whelan, who recused on Dec. 8, 2025, and it was reassigned to Battaglia. Bonta answered the complaint on Jan. 28, 2026. The plaintiffs filed the joint motion to pause the case on Aug. 28, 2026. A joint motion means both sides asked for it.
The fight is over how California classifies these launchers. As quoted in the complaint, Penal Code § 17240(a) defines tear gas as “any liquid, gaseous or solid substance intended to produce temporary physical discomfort or permanent injury through being vaporized or otherwise dispersed in the air.” Section 17250 defines a tear gas weapon to include any “revolver, pistol, fountain pen gun … or other form of device … intended for the projection or release of tear gas.”
Section 22810(e)(1) allows tear gas possession solely for self-defense. The complaint says that permission covers only aerosol pepper spray canisters of 2.5 ounces or smaller. The same statute bars buying, possessing, or using “any tear gas weapon that expels a projectile, or that expels the tear gas by any method other than an aerosol spray.” Section 22900 makes it a crime to manufacture, sell, or transport tear gas weapons not authorized in the state.
A small can of pepper spray, legal. The same kind of irritant fired from a launcher, a crime.
These launchers run on CO₂ or other compressed gas and use no gunpowder. They fire thin polymer rounds that break on impact and release an irritant powder, typically oleoresin capsicum (OC) or its synthetic equivalent, PAVA. The plaintiffs say each round strikes with 8 to 12 foot-pounds of force, comparable to a paintball, and the irritant effect typically wears off within 30 minutes. Byrna’s civilian launchers require a separate trigger pull for each shot. The magazine on its most popular civilian model holds five projectiles.
The complaint lays out what the ban means for each plaintiff. Schiller wants a launcher for self-defense at home and to carry in public, and says she has held off buying one because of the law. On June 12, 2025, Alonso-Martinez tried to order a launcher from PepperBall.com. When he entered his Anaheim shipping address, the checkout page displayed “This item cannot be shipped to your location,” citing California law. An Amazon order the next day was rejected for the same reason. Byrna says it has sold more than 60,000 launchers in California, but only with non-chemical “kinetic” rounds, which the complaint describes as hard, solid plastic spheres. It cannot sell its pepper rounds in the state.
The legal argument leans on Caetano v. Massachusetts, in which a unanimous Supreme Court held that stun guns are “arms” protected by the Second Amendment. It also relies on Heller, which protects arms in common use for lawful purposes. To show common use, the plaintiffs say Byrna alone had sold roughly 750,000 launchers nationwide as of September 2025, and more than 1 million are possessed by law-abiding citizens. They also say California and New York are the only states that criminalize them for ordinary citizens. The complaint adds that the Los Angeles Police Department and the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department use pepper projectile launchers.
The plaintiffs ask for a ruling declaring the ban unconstitutional and a permanent injunction, a court order barring the state from enforcing it. Those are the plaintiffs’ allegations, and the court has not ruled on the merits.
More from USA Carry:
- Always Have a Personal Survival Kit with You
- Intruders w/ Pepper Spray Demanded Money & Valuables; Got This Instead…
- Fort Worth Woman Pepper Sprays, Then Shoots Ex-Boyfriend Who Broke In
- 5 Self-Defense Weapons You Probably Ignored But Shouldn’t
- 11 Mother’s Day Gifts for the Concealed Carrier in Your Life
Not everyone who wants a defensive option wants a firearm, and some who carry one want a less-lethal tool as well. A sound self-defense mindset includes knowing which tools your state allows and where the legal lines fall. For those who carry a handgun in the state, my guide to California concealed carry laws covers the permit side.
I will continue tracking Schiller v. Bonta and the Supreme Court rulings it now waits on.
Read the original story: Pepper Spray Legal, Pepper Launcher a Crime: Federal Judge Pauses Byrna and Two Californians’ Second Amendment Challenge Until Supreme Court Rules