Winchester Backed Down on Gun Ban After $37,000 in Legal Payments, FOIA Records Reveal

Winchester has been here before. On February 9, 2021, City Council voted 7-2 along party lines to ban guns and ammunition in city government buildings, in city parks and at permitted events such as the Shenandoah Apple Blossom Festival. Council’s only two Republicans, Les Veach and Corey Sullivan, voted no. Of the 18 residents who spoke that night, all but one opposed the ban. The city relied on a Virginia law, effective July 1, 2020, that authorized localities to prohibit firearms in buildings and on property they own or use for governmental purposes.
Gun control groups celebrated that law. It was House Bill 421, part of the gun control package the General Assembly majority elected in 2019 passed in 2020. Giffords, the gun control group, describes it as giving local communities “the authority to establish their own gun laws in government buildings, public parks, recreation/community centers, and at public events.” Everytown for Gun Safety says Gov. Ralph Northam announced he had signed the bills on a press call with Everytown and Moms Demand Action. Everytown also says it and Moms Demand Action ran a statewide campaign to flip the General Assembly, and that its political arms spent more than $2.5 million on it. Once the law took effect, Moms Demand Action cheered the local bans as they passed. “Each ordinance keeping guns out of sensitive places is a win for public safety,” a Virginia Moms Demand Action volunteer said in September 2020, when Richmond and Charlottesville acted. Winchester passed its ban five months later. No record reviewed for this story shows a gun control group lobbying Winchester’s council directly, but the city used exactly the power that campaign won.
The ban did not hold. Local residents, businesses, and national gun rights groups sued in Winchester Circuit Court in April 2021. After a September 2022 ruling, City Attorney Melisa Michelsen proposed removing the bans on guns in parks and at city-permitted events. The rewritten ordinance itself states that “a Virginia court has interpreted certain portions of the City Code” to “not be grounded in historic tradition.” Council approved the rewrite 7-2 in November 2022, again with Veach and Sullivan opposed, and kept the ban on city buildings. That building ban is the provision the parking garage lawsuit challenged, and the city carved the garages out of it in May 2026. That makes two court fights and two retreats, and the legal payments on the second one alone top $37,000.
The City of Winchester, Virginia, spent more than two years defending a ban on guns in its public parking garages. Records the city released under the Virginia Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) show more than $37,000 in legal payments tied to the fight. When the city was asked how much its defense lawyers charged per hour, and for the invoices that would show what the money bought, it said it had no additional records.
The case never went to trial. Before a judge ruled on whether a parking garage can be a gun-free zone, the city changed its own law, and the lawsuit was thrown out as moot.
The Money
A payment report for claim number 02-23-56091-1-PO, with claimant Patrick Hyland and a loss date of January 12, 2024, shows seven checks to the law firm McGavin, Boyce, Bardot, Thorsen & Katz, P.C. Each one is marked “Defense Attorney” under the department “City Attorney.”
- August 1, 2024: $10,630.32
- November 12, 2024: $6,855.70
- December 11, 2024: $2,986.59
- March 21, 2025: $1,481.87
- September 18, 2025: $2,679.00
- October 28, 2025: $1,281.50
- June 12, 2026: $9,947.80
The seven checks total $35,862.78 and cover work from January 12, 2024, through June 3, 2026.
A separate invoice from Litten & Sipe, L.L.P., a Harrisonburg firm, shows the city attorney’s own bill. Invoice HY08104, dated October 5, 2026, and submitted to City Manager John Piper, is labeled “Hyland Matter.” It lists $1,310.00 for 5.1 hours of work and is marked as paid. Together, the two documents show $37,172.78 in legal payments tied to the Hyland matter, although some Litten & Sipe entries also cover the related Stickley and VCDL matters.
What the City Can’t Say
The Litten & Sipe invoice spells everything out. It has 19 dated entries, each with the time spent, the rate, and a short description. The rate was $250 an hour through July 2025 and $275 an hour in 2026. Anyone can see that 12 minutes of emails on May 9, 2024, about the “Hyland lawsuit re: gun ban ordinance” cost the city $50.
The defense firm’s payments come with none of that. The payment report gives a check number, a date, the billing period, and a total. It shows no hours, no rate, and no description of the work.
On October 30, 2026, a supplemental Virginia FOIA request asked for exactly those missing pieces. It sought every invoice paid to or requested by McGavin, Boyce, Bardot, Thorsen & Katz in the Hyland matter, along with detailed time entries and documentation of the hourly rate the firm charged to defend the city. On November 5, 2026, the city replied that it “has reviewed its files and has determined there are no additional responsive documents to your request.” The city’s records portal lists the request, reference number W008638-103026, as “No Responsive Records.”
The rate matters because it decides how much work the money bought. The records don’t give it, but simple division shows the range. At $200 an hour, $35,862.78 buys about 179 hours of lawyer time. At $250, the rate the city attorney charged through mid-2025, it buys about 143 hours. For $300, it buys about 120 hours, and at $400 it buys about 90. These figures are illustrations, not billing records. That is the problem: without the invoices, nobody can tell from the records released which one is true.
The largest single check, $10,630.32, covered January 12 through July 27, 2024. That is the stretch when the lawsuit was filed, and the city agreed to an order blocking the ban in the garages. The last check, $9,947.80, covered October 27, 2025, through June 3, 2026, the period that ended with the city rewriting its own law. Between them, more than $20,000 was paid for two billing periods, and the city has produced no timesheet for either one.
The city attorney’s bill also shows lawyer time going to the public’s questions about the money. On June 10, 2024, Litten & Sipe billed $150 for emails about a “FOIA request for Stickley/Hyland legal bills paid by the City” and for beginning to review Bardot’s bills. On June 20, 2024, it billed $125 to review and redact “legal invoices relating to VCDL, Stickley and Hyland lawsuits.” In all, the invoice bills $400 for FOIA-related work in June 2024.
How the Case Ended
The lawsuit, Hyland v. The City of Winchester in the Winchester Circuit Court, challenged the city’s ban on firearms in its public parking garages. The Gun Owners Foundation and the Virginia Citizens Defense League backed the challenge. On June 11, 2024, in an agreed order, the court barred the city from enforcing the ban in the parking garages named in the complaint.
The Litten & Sipe invoice tracks what followed: a hearing, a brief, a motion for summary judgment and the city’s response, discovery responses. Then, on April 18, 2026, an email with Piper and Bardot about the “Hyland lawsuit and amendment to gun ban ordinance.”
City Attorney Melisa Michelsen brought the change to City Council. It was scheduled for first reading on April 28, 2026, and for a public hearing and second reading on May 12. It added a new exception to the ban: “City-owned parking structures, garages, and decks that are open to the public.”
On May 26, 2026, on the city’s motion and without objection from Hyland, the court dissolved its June 2024 order and dismissed the case “as MOOT as a result of the Defendant’s May 12th, 2026 amendment.” The dismissal was without prejudice. No judge ever decided whether the garage ban was constitutional.
Why Fold?
The city has not said why it changed the ordinance. My read, and it is my opinion, is that Winchester saw a loss coming and chose not to let a court write it down.
After the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision, governments defending gun-free zones have to tie them to the nation’s history of firearm regulation. The Court pointed to legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses as places where such bans were settled. A public parking garage is none of those. It is where people leave their cars on the way to somewhere else. Calling it a “sensitive place” was always a stretch, and by June 2024 the city had agreed to an order barring enforcement in the garages.
Erich Pratt, senior vice president of Gun Owners of America, which says it won the case alongside GOF and VCDL, told the Daily Caller News Foundation that the case was nearing the point of deposing Winchester’s police chief when the city acted. “I think Winchester knew ultimately they saw the handwriting on the wall, and so they repealed their ordinance,” he said.
If that is right, more than $37,000 in legal fees went to defending a garage gun ban for over two years, only for the city to drop garages from the ban. And when they ask what their defense lawyers charged by the hour, the city says it has no additional records.
Editor’s Note: This article is based on legal payment records, attorney billing documents, court proceedings, and correspondence obtained through the Virginia Freedom of Information Act. The financial figures reflect the records AmmoLand News reviewed. The City of Winchester’s response to the supplemental FOIA request stated that no additional responsive documents were found. Nothing in these records, standing alone, establishes financial misconduct or a violation of Virginia’s Freedom of Information Act.
About John Crump
Mr. Crump is an NRA instructor and constitutional activist with more than 26 years of experience in networking and cybersecurity for major Fortune 100 companies. John has written about firearms, the Constitution, and cybersecurity, and has interviewed people from all walks of life. John lives in Northern Virginia with his wife and sons. Follow him on X at @right2bear, or at www.crumpy.com.